An Egyptian man embraced an army commander in Cairo’s Tahrir Square Saturday morning.
By KAREEM FAHIM
Published: February 12, 2011
CAIRO — As a new era dawned in Egypt on Saturday, the army leadership sought to reassure Egyptians and the world that it would shepherd a transition to civilian rule and honor international commitments like the peace treaty with Israel.
Exultant and exhausted opposition leaders claimed their role in the country’s future, pressing the army to lift the country’s emergency law and release political prisoners and saying they would present their vision for the government. And they vowed to return to Tahrir Square next week to celebrate a victory and honor those who had died in the 18-day uprising that toppled Hosni Mubarak after nearly 30 years of authoritarian rule.
In an announcement broadcast on state television, an army spokesman said Egypt would continue to abide by all its international and regional treaties and the current civilian leadership would manage the country’s affairs until the formation of a new government. But he did not discuss a timetable for any transfer of power, and it was unclear how and when talks with opposition figures would take place.
The army spokesman said the military was “aspiring to guarantee the peaceful transition of power within the framework of a free democratic system that allows an elected civilian power to rule the country, in order to build a free democratic state.”
The impact of Egypt’s uprising rippled across the Arab world as protesters turned out in Algeria, where the police arrested leading organizers, and in Yemen, where pro-government forces beat demonstrators with clubs.
The Palestinian leadership responded by announcing that it planned to hold presidential and parliamentary elections by September. And in Tunisia, which inspired Egypt’s uprising, hundreds demonstrated to cheer Mr. Mubarak’s ouster.
Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, will travel to Jordan and Israel for talks as both countries deal with the reverberations from Egypt’s revolution.
In Tahrir, or Liberation, Square, some members of the broad movement that toppled Mr. Mubarak vowed to continue their protests, saying that all their demands had not yet been met.
A long list included an end to the emergency law that allows detention without charges, the dissolution of the Parliament, seen as illegitimate, and for some of the protesters, the prosecution of Mr. Mubarak. About 50 stood in the square on Saturday morning, as the military removed barricades and concertina wire on the periphery.
But the uprising’s leading organizers, speaking at a news conference in central Cairo, asked protesters to leave the square.
The group, the Coalition of the Youth of the Revolution, which includes members of the April 6 Youth Movement, the Muslim Brotherhood Youth and young supporters ofMohamed ElBaradei, a prominent opposition figure, said that it had not yet talked with the military and that on Sunday it would lay out its road map for a transitional government.
The coalition said that Ahmed Zewail, a Nobel laureate in chemistry, and other respected figures would work as intermediaries between the youth group and the country’s new military chiefs.
“The power of the people changed the regime,” said Gehan Shaaban, a group spokeswoman. “But we shouldn’t trust the army. We should trust ourselves, the people of Egypt.”
Again, there were signs that not all the protesters were willing to give up. During the news conference, a woman yelled: “We should all head to Tahrir and stay there, until we ourselves are sure that everything is going as planned! The government of Ahmed Shafiq has to go!” Mr. Shafiq is the prime minister. The woman’s shouts brought the news conference to a close.
As the protesters and opposition groups prepared an agenda, they sought clues about exactly whom they were negotiating with. On Friday, Vice President Omar Suleiman said that Mr. Mubarak had authorized the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces to manage the state’s affairs, marking the transition from civilian to military rule.
Mr. Suleiman, a former general who became Egypt’s foreign intelligence chief, straddled the two worlds. But Hosam Sowilam, a retired general, said Mr. Suleiman no longer played a leadership role. “Omar Suleiman finished his time,” he said. “He’s 74 years old.” Others were not so quick to dismiss Mr. Suleiman, a close ally of Mr. Mubarak who was mentioned as his successor.
In interviews, protest leaders said they assumed that the defense minister, Field Marshal Mohamed Hussein Tantawi, 75, who was considered a loyalist of Mr. Mubarak, was now the country’s de facto leader. On Saturday morning, his convoy tried to drive to Tahrir Square, according to a paratrooper stationed there. But he did not leave his car.
The military chiefs worked quickly to exert their influence, calling on citizens to cooperate with the police, after weeks of civil strife, and urging a force stained by accusations of abuse and torture to be mindful of the department’s slogan: “The police in the service of the people.”
Security officials said that the recently appointed interior minister, Mahmoud Wagdy, visited units of the department’s feared security services on Saturday, in the hope of returning police officers to work. The officers vanished from Egypt’s streets on Jan. 29 after violent clashes with protesters, and only small numbers have returned.
Reuters reported that Field Marshal Tantawi met with Mr. Wagdy to discuss the officers’ return.
That security force, including plainclothes officers widely accused of abuse, are loathed by the protesters, who have demanded police reform to end brutality and, in particular, torture in police stations. Prosecutors are weighing charges against the previous interior minister, Habib al-Adly, who seemed to ignore or encourage police abuses. But some analysts have suggested that he is a scapegoat, and that the real problem was a government that relied on harsh tactics.
At the same time, neighborhoods in Cairo and other cities have for weeks been forced to function without the police. The lack of public safety was underscored on Friday, when security officials said hundreds of inmates, freed by armed gangs, escaped from a prison in Cairo.
While the Egyptian military’s commitment to international treaties reassured the United States and Israel, there was no indication whether such a pledge would survive a new government. The protesters in the square made it clear that they would reconsider all of Mr. Mubarak’s foreign alliances, and many frequently referred to the deposed president as an Israeli or American agent.
Hamdy Hassan, a former member of Parliament from the Muslim Brotherhood, said the military had “acknowledged the revolution’s legitimacy,” but added that there were still doubts about its intentions. “We want a guarantee that we do not have another tyrant.”
In Cairo, citizens embraced their new reality with humor, mild arguments and celebrations. The official state press gave a measure of the changes.
“The People Toppled the Government” said the headline in Al Ahram, the flagship state-owned national newspaper and government mouthpiece, borrowing a line from the protest movement. Another article noted that Switzerland had frozen the assets of Mr. Mubarak and his aides.
On state television, which for weeks depicted the protesters as a violent mob of foreigners, an anchor spoke of the “youth revolution.”
Security officials said Saturday that the information minister, Anas el-Fekky, who many of the protesters say should be fired, was placed under house arrest.
In Tahrir Square on Saturday, thousands of volunteers who brought their own brooms or cleaning supplies swept streets and scrubbed graffiti from buildings. On the streets around the square, the celebrations from the night before continued, spurred on by honking drivers.
At night, the party started early, as tens of thousands of Cairo residents and visitors from all over Egypt filled the square, dancing and snapping pictures of their children standing on vigilant tanks.
The president’s departure to his home by the Red Sea in Sharm el Sheik seemed for some to have stripped the country’s political woes of some urgency.
Mr. ElBaradei’s brother, Ali ElBaradei, said Mr. ElBaradei was taking the day off and had not been contacted by the military. “They will call when they call,” he said.
Amr Hamzawy, who has acted as a mediator between the protesters and the government, said that “everyone is taking a break,” though he expressed concern with the vague nature of the army’s most recent statements.
“What is the timeline we are looking at?” he said. “Is it September?” He also said it was unclear whether the army council ruling the country favored amending the Constitution or starting from scratch, which is the preferred solution for many of the protesters.
There was also no clear sign from the military about whether it intended to dissolve Parliament, Mr. Hamzawy said, adding that so far the military’s tone had been “very, very positive.”
Questions
- What are your views on the protests in Egypt?
- Imagine that you are Egyptian, what would you want in a government?
- What are some of the benefits of the Singaporean political system?
- Do you think Egypt will become a democratic state or the will the military consolidate power?
If you have any other thoughts or ideas please feel free to share them
Original article from New York Times
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/13/world/middleeast/13egypt.html?sq=egypt&st=cse&scp=8&pagewanted=all
1. What are your views on the protests in Egypt?
ReplyDeleteThe protests seem to be very serious to me and I believe the protests will have a long term effect and impact on the society in Egypt. Egypt is far from us in the world geography but is near in such ways of the realisation of the consequences that will affect Egypt and some of the countries economy .Because the protests have toppled Hosni Mubarak after nearly 30 years of authoritarian rule. Is it human factor and strength that overthrow him or is it because of guilt that he stepped down? Nevertheless there seem to be a celebration among the protestors after him stepped down. In my point of view, the people should not be rejoicing because the step down may cause the fall in Egypt economy .there is still a fight going on among the spirit of the people in Egypt, after 30 years of authorisation rule ,can the people cope with complete civilian rule and democratic society ? The long term consequences are that the people unity might not be as strong as before Egyptians might not really trust what various politicians say. It also affect Egypt through the action of a protest .Singapore might be affected as it is a trading hub, it might trade with Egypt and the affected countries. Anyway, I believed they should not start the protest in the first place, they should have organize a negotiation or discussion with the government calmly .If they did so, it might not result in the large numbers of casualties
2. Imagine that you are Egyptian, what would you want in a government?
I would want the government to work with us, towards a win -win situation .I want the government to listen to what we say than just ordering us to do something with the authority. The government should be peace loving and should follow, adhere to the rules by the international organisaions. The government should be democratic, we should be able to choose our leader through voting. The transfer of power should be clear if it take place.
3. What are some of the benefits of the Singaporean political system?
Singapore political system is democratic. It ensures that corruption in the country will be heavily dealt with and Singaporeans will be treated fairly, regardless of race, language or religion. This is just like what the pledge says. It makes sure we will work towards a common goal, united as one. We will make Singapore thrive! Singapore political system ensures unity and fairness in the land.
4. Do you think Egypt will become a democratic state or the will the military consolidate power?
I think Egypt will most likely become a democratic state because the people emphasize on the benefits of the democratic state and they are persistent about it. I believed they would work hard towards the civilian rule. As shown in the photograph in the news, an Egyptian man embracing the army commander, the army is likely to ensure peace and harmony in the land and the only way to do that is to turn the state to democratic. A democratic state will benefit people in Egypt in the long term as civilian gets to make the decision that they want .Despite this , I believed there might be others who support military consolidate power as they may find this change troublesome or with other reasons. It is most likely that more people support democracy and it is the main reason to push the state towards democracy. I myself support democracy! Moreover, I believed that the military consolidate power is not able to lead the people and will not be able to hold the power for long.
By Chua Jia Sheng(28) 202 Nan Hua High School
(Add on)2.The government should consists of capable civilians and also minority foreign talents who will treat Egyptians equally .
ReplyDeleteBy Chua Jia Sheng(28) 202 Nan Hua High School
2, Imagine that you are Egyptian, what would you want in a government?
ReplyDeleteIf I am an Egyptian, I would absolutely want to be able to vote for a government of our own. The government should be comprised of capable yet trustworthy righteous candatites whom the people can rely on, especially in times of great need, and not corrupted officials who only work towards their own selfish goals. The government should be able to eliminate any obstacles in the way efficiently without the implications of underhand means. They ought to be able to empathise with the civilians too, so as to better understand what we need and want, therefore, choosing our very own leaders from the crowd would be a favourable way of electing our government. The government must be capable of meeting its people's needs as well as attending to their welfare, and not neglecting them. It should have faith in leading its citizens and governing the country too. I would also personally prefer a government that sets high aims for the nation as well as putting in efforts to achieve those goals. One, formed from elected candadites who are trustworthy, capable and righteous, that is capable of stabilizing the state of the country, governing the country efficiently and fairly, leading its people confidently, fufilling the needs of the people, taking good care of their welfare, empathising with them, ensuring the security and safety of the nation, maintaining law and order, aims to develop the country into a renowned state, pushing the country and its people beyond their limits, keeping peace with others and forging relations with the world, would be an ideal government for Egypt.
Posted by Lim Kai Jie (34) S2/02 Nan Hua High School
3; What are some of the benefits of the Singaporean political system?
ReplyDeleteSingapore, under the leadership of the PAP, possesses a distinct political culture: authoritarian, pragmatic, rational and legalistic. Singapore’s power structure is highly centralized, characterized by a top-down style. It features appointment rather than election to most offices. Economic growth and political stability were maintained by the paternal guidance of the PAP. Thus, Singapore is not administered by politicians, but by bureaucrats, in a meritocracy where power is gained through skill, performance, and loyalty to the nation and its policies. Furthermore, Singapore has a multi-racial and multi-religious character, where giving fair treatment to all races in education, housing and health is considered very important. The minorities are assured of equal representation in Parliament through the Group Representation Constituency or GRC system. There is a dominance of government-controlled companies in the local economy. But in spite of its powerful position, the Singapore government has maintained a clean, corruption-free image. In addition, rifts within the leadership in Singapore are rare. The mode of decision making is by consensus, and the leadership style is collective. Overall, the political system in Singapore has benefited it in countless various such as maintaining high laws and order, ensuring security of the nation, promoting racial harmony in our communities, meeting the needs and wants of the citizens, attending to the welfare of the people, free of corruption and disputes within, satisfying everyone, etc.
Posted by Lim Kai Jie (34) S2/02 Nan Hua High School
4-Do you think Egypt will become a democratic state or the will the military consolidate power?
ReplyDeleteI think that Egypt will most probably become a democratic state as can be inferred from the article above, which states the military in Egypt assuring the people that they will maintain peace and keep order in the country until the citizens have elected their own leaders, and the strong will of the people towards having civilian rule. If the military was to consolidate power, then the army, responsible for ensuring security of the land, would be defecting its purpose as an unavoidable clash would surely break out between them and the civilians since their opinions differ. I think t6hat that would not be what they wished for, another internal conflict amongst themselves just after the uprise.
Posted by Lim Kai Jie (34) S2/02 Nan Hua High School
1.What are your views on the protests in Egypt?
ReplyDeletePersonally, I feel that the protests in Egypt are only natural, as opinions of people would most certainly differ from one another, which is human nature, and that fact cannot be avoided. Although, I really do not see the need for use of violence when handling such political disputes. Are there no other better ways to solve this conflict other than resorting to violence? I also ponder why the civilians did not thought of the resulting consequences more thouroghly before actually leaping into action. The uprise seemed to be a sudden decision made despite the long period of unrest as long as thirty years. Did they not thought of the losses that will be incurred such as injuries and deaths on both sides which would in turn caused people to grieve over the loss of their loved ones. In this case, a peacetalk looks very inviting to me compared with a bloody fight. Why could both parties not agree to come together for a discussion on the current situation and peaceful negotiation? Who knows, the talk might produce positive results more efficiently and end the chaos quickly rather than thrashing things out brutally. Generally, I think that the Egyptians should not have implied violence as a way of solving problems though I do support their stand for democracy.
Posted by Lim Kai Jie (34) S2/02 Nan Hua High School
1. What are your views on the protests in Egypt?
ReplyDeleteI feel that fighting would not solve the problems and that it would only led to deaths and injuries. I feel that the best solution is a peace talk and that both parties should sit down and negotiate peacefully.
2. Imagine that you are Egyptian, what would you want in a government?
I would want democracy and be able to vote for my country's own government. The government should consist of people who are honest, trustworthy and reliable. They should also have a heart for the citizens and the country.
3. What are some of the benefits of the Singaporean political system?
Singaporean political system is democratic and also most importantly, multi-racial. The government ensures a balanced race in the seats of the parliament.
4. Do you think Egypt will become a democratic state or the will the military consolidate power?
I think that Egypt will most probably become a democratic state as the passage states that the citizens would elect their own leaders, thus showing democracy.
Done by: Ong Chin Hui (14) Class:304
sec 205 26
ReplyDeleteQ1.What are your views on the protests in Egypt?
my view of the protests in Egypt is that there meant o ouster the Egyptian president,Hosni Mubarak for thirty years of dictatorship. his people have enough of his rule and now they want something new, something which they can embrace freedom, something which allows them to speak freely-democracy
Q2.Imagine that you are Egyptian, what would you want in a government?
i do not want a dictator to rule my country. i want an elected president serving for an agreed term. as for the parliament, i want mps that are elected by the people. i want everyone to have an equal chance for politics i want something like the government in Singapore. in short i want democracy
Q3.What are some of the benefits of the Singaporean political system?
everyone can voice out their thoughts at the speaker's corner. anyone can support their political party as volunteers. anyone can acts at their mp for their constituency as independents during the general election. anyone can be nominated members of parliament or candidate for their party provided they have the requirement
Q4.Do you think Egypt will become a democratic state or the will the military consolidate power?
it depends if on how they handle things. if the people's leader are not smart or quick or united or strong, the military may take chance to consolidate power. if the military wants to follow the people's thinking or the military has a higher rate of defection to the people, Egypt may transform into a democratic state
Q1.What are your views on the protests in Egypt?
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, I think that the protests in Egypt are very serious as there are quite a lot of causalities. Therefore, I feel that if they were to solve problem, they should not use violence and instead, have a talk to solve the issue. By solving the issue through peace talk, the country will not lose their people, neither will their economy fall.
Q2.Imagine that you are Egyptian, what would you want in a government?
I would want to be able to vote for our own government and have democracy in our country. Also, I want the government to be peace loving and listen to our opinions instead of deciding big issues for their own benefits instead of the whole country's benefits. Therefore, they should be honest and must be able to communicate with the people well for the country to be able to progress well.
Q3.What are some of the benefits of the Singaporean political system?
Everyone is treated fairly and we get to voice out our own opinions. We also get to choose and vote for our leaders for the country. Also, the leaders tend to put our opinions and welfare at the top priority. Therefore, Singapore is able to progress at a good pace with everyone working well together.
Q4.Do you think Egypt will become a democratic state or the will the military consolidate power?
I think Egypt will become a democratic state as as stated in the passage, the military is keeping peace in the country until the people can elect their own leaders.
Rachel Tan Lay Theng (16)
Class 202
1.What are your views on the protests in Egypt?
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, this protest were bound to happen as there were already a built up of discontentment among the civilions about Mubarak dictatorship. However, everyone has different opinions and there might be people who were content with status quo. With this sudden change to democracy, they may be unaccustomed to the change in leadership direction. Overall, they semed to celebrate Mubarak's stepping down, so I think that they welcomed the freedom in democracy and I believed that people would adapt overtime. At another point, they could have considered a more peaceful way in negeotiating this issue, as it would not cause in so many casualties.
2.Imagine that you are Egyptian, what would you want in a government?
I would want a government that treat everyone fairly and listen to the public for suggestions and implement some measures to cope with the problem that the public faced. They could communicate with the public and take the public's decision into account for major decisions. The government should respect the public and put the public's welfare first. The government should consist of people that have the public trust and vote, and is trustworthy and capable, a leader that is able to take Egypt to greater heights.
3.What are some of the benefits of the Singaporean political system?
The political system treats everyone fairly, and we practice meritocracy, people are promoted based on your compabilities. We had a say and vote in deciding decisions. The government also provide opportunities for the younger generation by allowing the older ministers to educate and make way for the younger generations to learn and to take over the country.
4.Do you think Egypt will become a democratic state or the will the military consolidate power?
I believe that Egypt will become a democratic state as I believe that the public wants to have a country that they have a say on deciding decisions. They would want to be free after 30 years of oppression from Mubarak. The passage also says that the millitary would keep peace until the civilians elect a new leader.
Joanne Tan Xin Yi(06)
Class 202
1. What are your views on the protests in Egypt?
ReplyDeleteI feel the protests in Egypt are a result of the autocratic rule of about 30 years by Mr. Mubarak. As the democracy had be passed from the Western to the other parts of the world, people begin to demand for equal rights and want to decide who to rule the country by themselves. What made the situation worst are the ineffiencies, such as rising price of food, which made the people feeling more disappointed towards the government. As people stand up to protest, others with the same views stand up and join in, causing the protests to grow over time.
It is hard for the government to stop the protest by just making few changes to the ruling system as the citizens are not only unhappy of a few policies but the whole government system as they can not voice their opinions.
2. Imagine that you are Egyptian, what would you want in a government?
I would like a democratic government which us, the people, can vote and decide who to rule over the country. Also, the leader would be able to listen to our voices and install policies base on our wishes with fairness and justice.
3. What are some of the benefits of the Singaporean political system?
Singapore adopts democracy. With this, people would decide who to become the ruler. Hence, if a minister wants to remain in his position, he must contribute to the country. This ensures the most capable and wise people be left in the parliament and continue to benefit the country.
Also, the Singapore government is divided into 3 categories, the legislative, the executive and the judiciary. By dividing the work load, every council can focus on their main area of responsibility and contribute to their fullest. In addition, it prevents the abusing of power. Therefore, corruption which had taken place in many countries’ government is less likely to happen in Singapore.
4. Do you think Egypt will become a democratic state or the will the military consolidate power?
I think it will become a democratic state. From the protests, we can see that the people want a government this is fair and listen to its people. Even if the military consolidate power, it will be for a short period of time as that is not what the people want and they will rise again to overthrow the government as what they had done now. Hence, a democratic state might not be established immediately but it will form overtime.
Wang yixuan (19) 308
cheng wei yang 205 26
ReplyDeleteQ1.What are your views on the protests in Egypt?
my views of the protest is that it is meant o overthrow a president with dictatorial power,Mr. Mubarak who has ruled Egypt for decades the people are fed up with his rule and want a change of government however, it is hard to say what will happen next as some of the hard-core protest's demands have not been meet
Q2.Imagine that you are Egyptian, what would you want in a government?
i want a government that embrace democracy, not one ruled by the military. i want a government where i can voice my thought freely, where nominated mps are voted by us ,where there are regular election where i can vote
Q3.What are some of the benefits of the Singaporean political system?
it allows to voice our thoughts freely such as the speaker's corner. we can also vote for our mps and president such as the presidential and general; election respectively
we can also have our nominated mps in parliament
Q4.Do you think Egypt will become a democratic state or the will the military consolidate power?
it depends oh how things are settled. if the people are unified, quick to react, smart and sly ,Egypt will not be taken over by the military but become a democratic state. however, if the people are weak,not unified,slow to react and the military is decisive, the military could size power and Egypt will be taken over by the military and not become a democratic state which comes back to square one
1) I felt worried to have that kind of condition in Egypt. the government ought to have better ruling.
ReplyDelete2) i would want the government to be fair and he could turn in to his own people and help us when needed instead of just concentrate on getting money.
3) it enforced some rules that kept Singapore in order.
4) it depends. if the government still is so stubborn and refused to listen the his own people, there is no hope of having peace in Egypt.
by ding jiawen from 208
1)The protests seem very serious to my and there are violence which should not be included. Althought it may seem it is natural that these will happen but the long term effects of there protests could leave a huge impact on the country. The government should take more responsibility in controling the country.
ReplyDelete2)I would want the government to treat the people equally. He should be approachable at all times. In times when we need help he should willingly give us a helping hand and not leave us behind unattended. He should also not just concentrate on ony money but the welfare of his people.
3)It enforced many rules like smoking. This allows the government to handle problems easiler since everything is enforced. This keeps Singapore in order with no coruptions and prevention of power abusing.
4)Egypt should become a democratic state. It is best because everyone wants to have things their way so they should be given a oppotunity to speak up their ideas. If it is military consolidate power, people will soon protest again sooner or later.
Pan Lifan(205)37
1. What are your views on the protests in Egypt?
ReplyDeleteAbout the protests in Egypt, I think that they are very serious. They are trying to solve the problem. However, I think the way they are trying to solve it is wrong as violence would not solve problems and only lead to bad ending. I think that solving the problem by getting both parties to sit down and have a talk peacefully. This way, it’s a win-win situation.
2. Imagine that you are Egyptian, what would you want in a government?
I would want to have democracy and I hope that the government will understand us. As Egyptians, I would want the government listen to our opinions and put them in consideration instead of making decisions themselves. Personally, I think in a government, the most important thing they must have is to communicate well with the people and respect their opinions.
3. What are some of the benefits of the Singaporean political system?
Singapore is a democratic country. Everyone is given a chance to say their opinions and that they are treated equally. Singapore government also enforces rules and laws that ensure that there will not be chaos in Singapore. This brought Singapore to greater heights.
4. Do you think Egypt will become a democratic state or the will the military consolidate power?
I think that Egypt will become a democratic state. The article has mentioned that the army is likely to ensure peace and harmony in the land and the military is keeping peace until the country elects their own leaders.
Lim Sher Min (09)
S202